| Season by season | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year | Team | Record | PF | PA | Top Pick | Top Scorer | Division | Playoffs |
| 1990 | Narcoossee | 6-7-1 | 473 | 510 | B. Thomas | TFL | Out | |
| 1991 | Narcoossee | 10-4-0 | N/A | N/A | B. Sanders | TFL | SB Final | |
| 1992 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | N/A | N/A | C. Miller | C. Miller | TFL | Out |
| 1993 | Narcoossee | 6-8-0 | N/A | N/A | D. Marino | D. Marino | Western | Out |
| 1994 | Narcoossee | 8-6-0 | 552 | 463 | J. Rice | J. Rice | Horshack | Out |
| 1995 | Narcoossee | 5-9-0 | 489 | 542 | B. Morris | E. Kramer | Horshack | Out |
| 1996 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | 499 | 471 | S. Young | T. Allen | Horshack | Out (PW) |
| 1997 | Narcoossee | 6-8-0 | 551 | 537 | S. Young | S. Young | Horshack | Out |
| 1998 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | 587 | 508 | C. Dillon | J. Anderson | Horshack | Out |
| 1999 | Narcoossee | 11-3-0 | 596 | 426 | B. Favre | B. Favre | Horshack | SB Final |
| 2000 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | 629 | 521 | K. Warner | K. Warner | Horshack | Out |
| 2001 | Narcoossee | 6-8-0 | 561 | 565 | R. Gannon | R. Gannon | Horshack | Out |
| 2002 | Narcoossee | 5-9-0 | 543 | 578 | S. Alexander | T. Brady | Muldoon | Out |
| 2003 | Narcoossee | 6-8-0 | 483 | 644 | P. Holmes | P. Holmes | Muldoon | Out (PW) |
| 2004 | Narcoossee | 9-5-0 | 649 | 529 | D. Culpepper | D. Culpepper | Muldoon | SB Quarter |
| 2005 | Narcoossee | 9-5-0 | 598 | 539 | S. Alexander | S. Alexander | Muldoon | SB Semi |
| 2006 | Narcoossee | 8-6-0 | 501 | 488 | C. Palmer | C. Palmer | Muldoon | SB Quarter |
| 2007 | Narcoossee | 11-3-0 | 648 | 509 | S. Jackson | B. Favre | Muldoon | SB Semi |
| 2008 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | 626 | 586 | F. Gore | K. Warner | Muldoon | Out (PW) |
| 2009 | Narcoossee | 8-5-1 | 603 | 510 | T. Brady | T. Brady | Muldoon | SB Quarter |
| 2010 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | 519 | 580 | D. Brees | D. Brees | Muldoon | Out (PW) |
| 2011 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | 538 | 558 | R. Mendenhall | D. Bailey | Muldoon | Out (PW) |
| 2012 | Narcoossee | 3-11-0 | 438 | 701 | M. Stafford | M. Stafford | Muldoon | Out |
| 2013 | Narcoossee | 5-9-0 | 519 | 593 | D. Martin | J. Graham | Muldoon | Out (PW) |
| 2014 | Narcoossee | 3-11-0 | 545 | 690 | A. Peterson | C. Newton | Muldoon | Out |
| 2015 | Narcoossee | 8-6-0 | 741 | 645 | A. Rodgers | A. Rodgers | Muldoon | Out (PW) |
| 2016 | Narcoossee | 8-6-0 | 691 | 652 | L. McCoy | L. McCoy | Sourdough | Out (PW) |
| 2017 | Narcoossee | 11-3-0 | 636 | 563 | M. Gordon | C. Newton | Sourdough | SB Semi |
| 2018 | Narcoossee | 3-11-0 | 558 | 653 | D. Johnson | D. Watson | Sourdough | Out |
| 2019 | Narcoossee | 7-7-0 | 616 | 639 | J. Conner | P. Rivers | Sourdough | Out (PW) |
| 2020 | Narcoossee | 9-5-0 | 759 | 711 | C. McCaffrey | D. Carr | Sourdough | SB Semi |
| 2021 | Narcoossee | 4-9-1 | 693 | 754 | P. Mahomes | P. Mahomes | Sourdough | Out |