| Season by season | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year | Team | Record | PF | PA | Top Pick | Top Scorer | Division | Playoffs |
| 1994 | Lackawanna | 10-4-0 | 599 | 433 | S. Young | S. Young | Kotter | SB Final |
| 1998 | Lackawanna | 9-5-0 | 595 | 496 | B. Favre | B. Favre | Kotter | Out |
| 1999 | Lackawanna | 9-5-0 | 595 | 562 | E. James | B. Johnson | Kotter | SB Final |
| 2000 | Lackawanna | 9-4-1 | 566 | 455 | S. Davis | R. Smith | Kotter | Out |
| 2001 | Lackawanna | 10-4-0 | 610 | 413 | D. McNabb | D. McNabb | Kotter | Out |
| 2002 | Lackawanna | 8-6-0 | 625 | 512 | T. Owens | T. Owens | Gambell | SB Quarter |
| 2003 | Lackawanna | 7-7-0 | 614 | 543 | R. Williams | J. Wilkins | Gambell | Out (PW) |
| 2004 | Lackawanna | 9-5-0 | 576 | 521 | J. Lewis | T. Green | Gambell | SB Semi |
| 2005 | Lackawanna | 9-5-0 | 593 | 596 | W. McGahee | B. Favre | Gambell | SB Quarter |
| 2006 | Lackawanna | 8-6-0 | 575 | 440 | R. Johnson | M. Bulger | Gambell | SB Final |
| 2007 | Lackawanna | 5-9-0 | 509 | 676 | L. Johnson | J. Kitna | Gambell | Out (PW) |
| 2008 | Lackawanna | 4-10-0 | 551 | 655 | M. Jones-Drew | A. Rodgers | Gambell | Out |
| 2009 | Lackawanna | 5-9-0 | 485 | 506 | D. Brees | D. Brees | Gambell | Out (PW) |
| 2010 | Lackawanna | 4-10-0 | 532 | 663 | P. Rivers | P. Rivers | Gambell | Out |
| 2011 | Lackawanna | 6-7-1 | 606 | 584 | A. Foster | M. Ryan | Gambell | Out (PW) |
| 2012 | Lackawanna | 5-8-1 | 542 | 556 | R. Gronkowski | B. Roethlisberger | Gambell | Out (PW) |
| 2013 | Lackawanna | 6-7-1 | 534 | 600 | A. Foster | T. Romo | Gambell | Out (PW) |
| 2014 | Lackawanna | 9-5-0 | 786 | 718 | R. Wilson | A. Brown | Gambell | Out (PW) |
| 2015 | Lackawanna | 7-7-0 | 595 | 562 | C. Anderson | D. Hopkins | Gambell | SB Quarter |
| 2016 | Lackawanna | 7-7-0 | 676 | 674 | O. Beckham | J. Winston | Cheechako | Out (PW) |
| 2017 | Lackawanna | 12-1-1 | 787 | 570 | D. Johnson | C. Wentz | Cheechako | SB Semi |
| 2018 | Lackawanna | 3-11-0 | 562 | 756 | L. Bell | C. Wentz | Cheechako | Out |