| . | Year | Team | Points |
 | 2010 | Anchorage Kitchen | 667 |
 | 2009 | Baltimore Barons | 641 |
 | 2008 | Dutch Harbor Dawgs | 691 |
 | 2007 | Arctic Gators | 757 |
 | 2006 | Dugway Experiments | 719 |
 | 2005 | Penobscot Wolfpups | 638 |
| 2004 | Penobscot Wolfpups | 795 |
 | 2003 | Lackawanna Lancers | 614 |
| 2002 | Dutch Harbor Dawgs | 697 |
| 2001 | Dutch Harbor Dawgs | 628 |
| 2000 | Baltimore Barons | 670 |
 | 1999 | Narcoossee Nose Apes | 596 |
 | 1998 | Alaska Oosiks | 675 |
| 1997 | Dutch Harbor Dawgs | 617 |
| 1996 | Dugway Experiments | 583 |
 | 1995 | Marley Wailers | 722 |
| 1994 | Lackawanna Lancers | 599 |
 | 1993 | Maryland Mania | N/A |
 | 1992 | Bagdad Red-Bellied Newts | N/A |
| 1991 | Alaska Oosiks | N/A |
 | 1990 | Netherworld Islanders | 560 |
|
|